The Lady Maria Fisher Trophy Trophy
For the best supporting role
| Year | Awarded To | Company |
| 1989 | Jon Wilkinson | Arnside Players |
| 1990 | Graham Dalton | Sedergh Theatre |
| 1991 | Sue Pidgeon | Arnside Players |
| 1992 | Jenny Shipley | Barrow AODS |
| 1993 | Helen Benson | Burton Amateurs |
| 1994 | Bill Shaw | Grange ADS |
| 1995 | Marilyn Green | Arnside Players |
| 1996 | Lesley Skelton | Barrow AODS |
| 1997 | Kath Smith | CATS |
| 1998 | Doreen Brockbank | Arnside Players |
| 1999 | Dawn Chojnacki and Jan Gough | Swarthmoor Drama Group |
| 2000 | Jane Duckworth | Ulverston Outsiders |
| 2001 | Olwyn McLean | Arnside Players |
| 2002 | Steven Beattie | SWSSS |
| 2003 | Jan Gough | Swarthmoor Drama Group |
| 2004 | Kenny Smyth | Barrow AODS |
| 2005 | Carol Hannah | Barrow AODS |
| 2006 | Kenny Smyth | Ulverston Outsiders |
| 2007 | Margaret Fox and Brenda Baxter | Gosforth ADS Ulverston Outsiders |
| 2008 | Beryl Dixon | CATS |
| 2009 | Benita Finch | Grange Drama |
| 2010 | Bridget Brice and Chris Barron | Ulverston Outsiders |
| 2011 | Jane France | CATS |
| 2012 | Sue Stokes | Burton ADS |
| 2013 | Lesley Skelton | CATS |
| 2014 | Jenny Schofield | CATS |
| 2015 | Jill Roper | Cockermouth ADS |
| 2016 | not awarded | |
| 2016 | not awarded | |
| 2017 | Jacqui Walker | Cockermouth ADS |